Friday, October 31, 2025

Antihero Review

Author: Gregg Hurwitz
Series: Orphan X #11
Publisher: Minotaur Books
Release Date: Feb. 10, 2026

A big thank you to Minotaur Books for a complimentary arc of this title for review. Opinions expressed are my own. 

This review first published in Mystery & Suspense Magazine

In the latest in this New York Times best-selling series, Evan Smoak takes on his most complex mission yet―one where he has to not only protect but also avenge, and find a way to balance vengeance with mercy.

Review:
Antihero by Author Gregg Hurwitz is a gut wrenching, action packed, heart stopping thriller. The eleventh book in the Orphan X series and quite possibly the most anguish filled book to date, the story grabbed me by the throat on the first page and never let go. I devoured this book in one sitting as there was never a time I felt I could hit pause and walk away in peace. Carve out alone time to read this one as it'll come for you like a long black train.

 The government raised and trained Orphan X to be a Black Op assassin, a lethal machine that performed upon command, no questions asked. Leary of decisions made by his superiors, he grabbed the first opportunity to go solo and disappeared underground. When he resurfaced, X aka Evan Smoak had reinvented himself as the Nowhere Man, a lethal, mysterious, emotionless man on a mission to get vengeance and justice for victims of violence who have nowhere else to turn. The Nowhere Man lives by a stringent set of commandments, one of which is number four, "Never make it personal". A rule he finds increasingly difficult to adhere to after being summoned to the lair of Luke Devin who's suffering a psychotic break and in need of Evan to keep an eye on volatile world events until he recovers. While there, Evan learns of a woman repeatedly brutalized and violated by soulless thugs after having been kidnapped from the subway in New York City. Vowing to find the woman and annihilate her tormenters, X leaves Joey in charge at Devine's and returns to the city. After locating the battered, traumatized woman, Evan is speechless and unable to comprehend when she tells him justice belongs to a higher power, not humans. Standing her ground, she extracts a painful promise from Evan that leaves him struggling with a deluge of emotions he isn't trained to decipher or manage. For the first time in his life, the Nowhere Man faces the dilemma of completing his mission while keeping his promise as he grabbles with conflicting emotions within, including the realization that there are people in his life he cares for. With that knowledge comes the paralyzing fear of losing them. With time running out and X's enemies converging on him from every direction, he’s left vulnerable and off-balance, conditions foreign to him that prove life threatening as he repeatedly ignores the commandment to never make it personal.

 Antihero is a major turning point in the life of Orphan X aka The Nowhere Man as he maneuvers a minefield of foreign emotions that conflict with his rigid training and mission. His disgust for the vile lowlifes that attack innocents propels him to use deadly force to prevent them from doing it again and yet his newly found humanity demands he find a way to balance the scales and avenge victims by inflicting pain, not final judgement. The developing relationship between X and Joey is heart touching, almost a father/daughter thing with Joey spreading her wings and Evan worrying about her safety. Another foreign emotion for him. As always, the pace is insane, increasing with each new revelation and shocking turn, and the tone is dire, at best.


Author Gregg Hurwitz has raised the bar high in Antihero gifting readers  a masterfully written, gripping story that exposes unfamiliar, deeply buried layers in Orphan X. Readers are sucked into the action as the Nowhere Man learns to navigate his emotions and conduct missions in a new, less permanent manner while staying true to his training and commandments. In spite of all the brutality and violence in this book, there's an undertone of hope, respect, faith, and trust woven throughout. Antihero will be a favorite among fans of the series as well as readers who favor high action, take no prisoners’ thrillers. A 2025 favorite for this reader, and one of the author’s best to date.

 Synopsis:

Once a black ops assassin for the government known as Orphan X, Evan Smoak broke with the program and went deep underground, using his operational rules and skills to help the truly desperate with nowhere else to turn.

When Luke Devine, one of the most powerful men in the world has a psychological crisis, Evan flies to the East Coast to meet Luke. While there, he learns of a young woman who was kidnapped off the New York City subway, clearly in danger and in need of aid. With no name and few clues, Evan and his team track down the missing woman, who was assaulted and abandoned. Evan offers his help―and sets out tracking down the young men responsible. But the woman insists that Evan abandon his usual methods―no vengeance and, in particular, no killing. Which will prove no easy feat given the mounting incoming threats from all sides. In a mission that takes Evan from coast to coast, from the poorest corners of society to the richest, Orphan X must figure out a way to protect the innocent, avenge the victimized, and balance justice, with a measure of mercy.

Tuesday, October 28, 2025

The Seven Rings Review

Author: Nora Roberts
Series: The Lost Bride #3
Publisher: St. Martins Press
Release Date: Nov. 18, 2025

Many thanks to St. Martin's Press for a complimentary arc of this title for review. Opinions expressed are my own.

Review first published in Mystery & Suspense Magazine

The #1 New York Times-bestselling author concludes her compelling Lost Bride trilogy as two women—one dead, one alive—prepare for a terrifying final showdown…

Review:
The Seven Rings is the final book in the Lost Bride Trilogy by Author Nora Roberts and one that concludes the overall story arc that began in the first book, Inheritance. The story develops over the course of all three books as do relationships making it important to read this trilogy in order of publication. 

 Sonya MacTavish inherited a magnificent, haunted manor with a heartbreaking history overlooking the angry sea in Maine. Over a period of years, seven brides came to the mansion, and seven brides died there at the hands of Hester, a dark, evil witch spirit who ripped the wedding ring off each brides’ hand in a jealous fit of rage before sending them to their deaths, thereby cursing the house and all future brides. Hester intends to take her place as reigning mistress of the manor and until that day comes, she resides in the Gold Room terrorizing all who dare enter her domain. Sonya is a descendant of the Poole family and, along with Owen Poole, has the gift of sight which enables her to see and feel some of the brides and former staff ghosts who live there waiting to be set free. Her unique ability to pass through a mystical mirror into the past allows Sonya to journey through time and bear witness to each bride's horrific murder over a period of years. To reside in the manor in peace, she must break the curse and banish Hester from the residence. Believing the key to doing that has something to do with the stolen wedding rings, Sonya and her three companions search each room and piece of furniture in the manor as they work towards restoring everything to its former glory. With each passing day and new revelation, they bring additional light, laughter, and love into the house feeding Hester's rage which manifests in various forms, each more deadly than the one before. Time is running out for Sonya. Will she survive the witch’s wrath and break the curse?

 Author Nora Roberts excels in rendering captivating stories centered around families, both birth and found family. Her writing ebbs and flows on pages filled with daily life routines, such as mealtimes and daily tasks, as tension slowly builds to the story climax. While some readers may find that the abundance of scenes like these slow the pace and distract from the action, I appreciate the time taken by the author to quietly build emotional connections between characters and present historical background. The story transitions seamlessly between past and present through Sonya's travels back in time as she learns more about the hopes and dreams of each person who once resided in the manor and the present day as she searches for the key to banishing the evil witch before another bride dies. As Hester's violence escalates into madness, a tone of malice steadily propels the pace forward as the story unfolds through the points of view of the four main characters, two couples - Sonya and Trey and Cleo and Owen. The developing relationship between them as couples and as four friends with a common goal is at the heart of this emotional story.

 The Seven Rings is an eerie ghost tale, an emotional story of family and the ties that bind them together: a story of good vs. evil, of perseverance, compassion, and love. Author Nora Roberts' signature style is evident throughout this spell binding, small town adventure into the land of haunted houses, evil witches, and battles to banish them by breaking a curse. As always, Roberts wraps it all up in the epilogue with a beautiful, happy ever after bow. Highly recommended to fans of the author and readers who enjoy paranormal romance and mystical realism.


Synopsis:
Long ago, Arthur Poole built a grand house overlooking the turbulent ocean, in a Maine village that bore his name. Today, Sonya MacTavish lives in that house—a manor that has been cursed for generations. Within its walls, she has witnessed the deaths of seven brides and the thefts of seven wedding rings. And now, to break the curse and banish a malevolent spirit once and for all, a difficult task must be completed.

After Sonya, her boyfriend, Trey, and their friends are forced to hear, see—and feel—the suffering of the house’s many ghosts as their torment is reenacted by the evil presence, their bond only strengthens and their anger is renewed. Refusing to let her spirit be broken, Sonya searches each room for clues to her ancestors’ hidden story, putting the picture together, unearthing small treasures, and uncovering the moments of joy that existed among the sorrows. She’s determined to bring light to this haunted place—to fill it with people, with life and hope, once again.

But the enemy in the black dress continues to hover, to come at her in frightening forms. They may be illusions—but illusions can be powerful enough to wound and kill. She feeds on fear, and lies are her weapon. This dark-hearted witch wants to be mistress of Poole Manor, at any cost. And Sonya will need to fight a battle across two realms to finally take possession of the house on the clifftop—and of her own future…

Monday, October 27, 2025

The Sister's Curse Review

Author: Nicola Solvinic
Publisher: Berkley
Release Date: Oct. 21, 2025

Special thanks to Berkley for a complimentary arc of this title for review. Opinions expressed in this review are my own.

First published in Mystery & Suspense Magazine

There’s something in the water in Bayern County…

When mysterious drownings plague her small town, a detective haunted by her serial killer father must uncover whether revenge, ancient legends, or something darker lurks beneath the surface.

Review:
The Sister's Curse is a brilliantly rendered, chilling paranormal thriller that hooked this reader the moment I cracked open the cover, refusing to let go even after I read the final page. Author Nicola Solvinic seamlessly blends folklore, magical realism, procedural crime, Gothic horror and domestic drama in this mesmerizing follow up psychological thriller to last year's critically acclaimed The Hunter's Daughter in which readers were introduced to protagonist Lt. Anna Koray, the daughter of a serial killer. I'll admit to being skeptical that the author could deliver another masterpiece like the first book, but I'm delighted to say she delivered in spades, raising the bar to another level. Clear your schedule and settle into your favorite reading spot before starting this one because it'll grab and hold you to the volatile end.

 Lt. Anna Koray has settled in Bayern County, where legends, myths, and curses thrive. While Anna's still haunted by dark memories and nightmares of her serial killer father's final days, she's moving toward the light with a man she loves and her loyal dog by her side. All's good until the day she jumps in a lake to save a young boy who's drowning only to find herself fighting against an evil force that's sucking her and the boy under the water. When they finally escape, Anna is shocked at the strange marks on the boy's body as well as on her own. What evil lurks beneath the dark, swirling water? Was this an accident or is something more sinister brewing here? Days later, another victim is pulled from another lake with the same strange marks, leaving Anna's warning bells sounding. Something or someone is killing people in Bayern County. As it turns out, all the victims have a connection to a group of influential, wealthy men known as the Kings of Warsaw Creek. The same group of men who were accused, but not convicted, of being involved in the unsolved disappearance of a young girl years ago in which the sister vowed revenge. As the story unfolds, Anna is reminded she needs to tread carefully while conducting her investigation or suffer the consequences. With each new revelation, she’s drawn deeper into the darkness suffering extended periods of paranoia and illusions when she can't distinguish reality from dreams. What's happening to her? Is her biggest fear coming true? Has she inherited her father's evil traits? Is she truly her father's daughter? 

 Small town secrets and rumors abound in The Sister's Curse, a haunting tale that explores the age-old themes of nature vs. nurture and the life-altering effects of childhood trauma. Anna is a strong yet emotionally fragile protagonist who remains tormented by a deep-seated fear of inheriting her father's genes and propensity for ritualistic killing despite her vow to protect not harm. Her emotional psyche is tenuous at best as she's also scarred by her mother's accusations and abandonment and by vague memories surfacing about her mother's shadowy activities during periods of time when her father wasn't home. The story alternates between the present and flashbacks to Anna's childhood relayed through Anna's point of view. The well-timed pace steadily increases as the violence and Anna's hallucinations accelerate throughout the story, propelling an alarming tone of malice. A well-developed support cast muddies the water with a sordid range of possible villains, challenging readers to sift through the clues to solve the case and mystery. The Hunter's Daughter explored Anna's relationship with her father; The Sister's Curse takes a deep dive into her relationship with her mother both of which contribute to Anna's fractured psyche.

 The Sister's Curse is a hauntingly beautiful, evocative masterpiece of magical realism that takes a closer look at the long-lasting, potentially deadly results of childhood trauma and family abandonment in an age-old battle of good vs. evil and men vs. women. Highly atmospheric, the tension ladened story immerses readers in a mystic world where witches cast curses, the darker side of man rears its' ugly head, and enraged women seek vengeance. Steeped in legends, myths, folklore and the supernatural, Lillie's lyrical prose and vivid imagery catapult this story to the next level. Highly recommended for fans of mystical realism, paranormal mysteries, and dark thrillers.


Synopsis:
Lieutenant Anna Koray thought she'd finally found solid ground and escaped her past as the daughter of a notorious serial killer. A loving boyfriend, a loyal dog, a life that almost feels normal—except darkness has a way of seeping in. When she saves a boy from drowning, the strange marks on his body tell a disturbing something in the depths tried to drag him under.

Days later, another victim surfaces with identical marks and Anna's instincts scream that these are no accidents. Both victims are connected to the Kings of Warsaw Creek—men of the town's wealthiest and most influential families. And they have enemies.

Others whisper that there are witches in Bayern County, seeking revenge for a long-ago murder. Perhaps it's the work of Vivian Carson, the enigmatic bartender who’s rumored to cast hexes on those who wrong her. Or maybe it’s a secret coven who’s been leaving serpentine symbols and skulls behind at the scenes of the drownings.

But Anna's investigation reveals an even more sinister something is stirring in the water, and it wants the Kings to pay.

With time running out and more victims appearing, Anna must separate superstition from truth. But in Bayern County, where legends and curses run deep as the water itself, one wrong step could drag her into the depths—this time for good.

Sunday, October 19, 2025

Rifle Season Review

Author: Pat Kelly
Series: Mace Winters #1
Publisher: Atria
Release Date: Jan. 27, 2026

Special thanks to Atria Books for a complimentary arc of this title for review. Opinions expressed in this review are my own.

Review first published in Mystery & Suspense Magazine

A game hunter is in a race against time to save his family from the most dangerous predator on earth—other people—in this high-stakes thriller in the vein of Jack Carr and Peter Heller.

Review:
Rifle Season is a dark, gritty, propulsive debut novel by Author Pat Kelly that introduces readers to Mason (aka Mace) Winters whose legendary reputation as an expert big game hunter and guide in Colorado was besmirched after a hunting accident saddles him with an involuntary manslaughter conviction. Now he spends his days in a drunken haze picking up trash in the same wilderness he once stalked as a guide for wealthy big game hunters. Mason's lucrative career and marriage are already on the rocks when two mysterious strangers hire him as a guide for a photo shoot of an elusive mountain lion. When they return to his home on opening day of rifle season requesting his services again, Mason ignores the warning bells sounding in his gut in favor of earning big bucks he desperately needs and repairing his damaged reputation. By the time he realizes they're foreign operatives on a mission to assassinate a warlord that's hunting trophy elk in the higher elevation with a friend of Mason's, his fate is sealed. With a blizzard blowing in, Mason's only choice is to play along and wait for a chance to overtake them. Rusty though they are, he'll match his uncanny skills to theirs any day of the week, especially on this terrain. Afterall, these mountains are his stomping ground. One he knows like the back of his hand. With his and his wife's life at stake, Mason needs to clear his head and call on his ingrained survival skills to become the deadly predator he once was. This is a winner take all game. He has one shot at saving lives. One shot at redemption. Failure is not an option.

 When I heard Rifle Season being compared to C. J. Box's Open Season, I knew I had to read it, and I'm happy to say it surpasses the hype. Kelly wastes no time transporting readers into the middle of a deadly game of cat and mouse beginning with the chilling prologue and ending with the final incredible shot. His descriptive narrative brings scenes to life as both breathtakingly beautiful and life threatening at the same time. An insane pace is propelled by a tone of malice and the fear of time running out. In-depth characterizations are spot on, relatable, and believable. Mason's anguish and despair can be felt in the beginning as can his stone-cold determination and rage throughout. The author nails the essence of who he is and what he'll do to save those he loves as he struggles to hold it together. The same holds true even for the villains in this story. They're professionally written, despicable, and yet convincing. As the story unfolds, the stakes are raised with every shocking plot twist until the violence explodes on the page leaving readers to figure out if anyone survived.

 Author Pat Kelly scrutinizes the age-old tradition of hunting and man's moral rights as it pertains to the sport as well as his coexistence with nature in Rifle Season. Themes of revenge, forgiveness, redemption, and justice are evident throughout this well-written, masterful thriller. The author does an excellent job highlighting man's conservancy of nature and wildlife in a chilling battle of the fittest. Rifle Season reads like it's written by an expert, well-seasoned author with several titles under his/her belt making it hard to believe this is Kelly's debut novel. I hope there will be many more books in the series. Nature and hunting advocates will devour this book as will fans of fast-paced, explosive, second-chance thrillers. Rifle Season will be one of my top five reads of the year.


Synopsis:
Mason “Mace” Winters, with his acclaimed reputation as one of the best big game hunters in Colorado, lives for the thrill of the hunt. His lucrative career guiding the wealthy on intense hunts through the Colorado mountains is suddenly brought to a stop when an accident hangs an involuntary manslaughter conviction around his neck. Now he’s relegated to a life of trash pickup in the very wilderness where his prowess as a tracker and killer was the stuff of legends.

At rock bottom, Mace descends into a haze of Tito’s and sativa when two strangers seek him out. They wave enough cash under his nose to convince him to help them up into the mountains he knows so well on the opening day of Colorado’s rifle season. An innocent enough request, and the perfect cover for the trip’s true to assassinate an infamous warlord. All at once, Mace goes from unwitting to unwilling accomplice and it will take all his now dusty skills to outfox his patrons in their deadly game.

Saturday, October 18, 2025

The Bone Thief Review

Author: Vanessa Lillie
Series: Syd Walker #2
Publisher: Berkley
Release Date: Oct. 28, 2025

Many thanks to Berkley for a complimentary arc of this title for review. Opinions expressed are my own.

Review first publisher in Mystery & Suspense Magazine

When a Native teenager vanishes from her small town—a place with dark ties to an elite historical society—archaeologist Syd Walker is called to investigate...from bestselling author Vanessa Lillie.

Review:
The Bone Thief by Author Vanessa Lillie is the follow up novel to Blood Sisters in which readers were introduced to Syd Walker, a Cherokee archeologist for the Bureau of Indian Affairs. While this series is fictional, many of the events explored within both books are deeply rooted in American History and remain real-life issues for Indigenous people living on reservations today. Lillie does an admirable job of seamlessly incorporating history with fiction to deliver a thought provoking, heartbreaking mystery that's impossible to put down.

 BIA Agent Syd Walker has returned to the Narragansett Reservation in Rhode Island when she learns skeletal remains that may be those of a 300-year-old Indian sachem have been discovered on contested land now in the hands of the Founders' Society, an elite group of privileged people claiming to trace their heritage back to the first colonists. Syd assists in the archeological recovery; however, is forced to secure and leave the remains in the grave overnight. When she returns in the morning with tribal members, the grave is empty. At the same time, Syd learns a Native woman she knows is missing, and authorities are dismissing her as a runaway. Syd suspects otherwise and quietly begins her own investigation. When she uncovers a long history of missing girls and artifacts with possible ties to powerful, privileged families within the Founder's Society, she realizes exposing them and the dark secrets they've kept buried is the only way to unveil the truth even though doing so puts her on a killer's radar. Syd's vow to reap justice for the missing women never wavers even at the cost of her own safety.

 Syd Walker is a determined, tenacious protagonist whose own native heritage makes her the perfect advocate for the rights of the Narragansett tribe; however, she finds herself torn between returning artifacts and skeletal remains to their rightful people and the opportunity to educate all people on Native history by displaying them in museums. The author's impressive three-dimensional characterizations are realistic, evoking empathy from readers. A tension ladened, multi-layered plot line and taut writing drive a fast pace throughout this engaging story with vivid descriptive passages drawing readers into the heart of the conflict. As I was reading, an overbearing sense of dread, of impending doom, left chill bumps on my arms.

 Author Vanessa Lillie draws on her own heritage, life experiences and professionally researched American History to deliver a powerful, captivating story in The Bone Thief. The high rate of poverty, addiction, and economic struggles are well documented as are the suspicious disappearances of Indigenous women and the appalling theft of Native artifacts and skeletal remains. Lillie’s mission to draw attention to the legacy of violence and corruption that continues to surround Native Americans today is remarkable and noteworthy

 The Bone Thief is a riveting, thought-provoking, must-read mystery, a perfect blend of truth and fiction that resonated with this reader for days after reading the last action-packed page. The author’s portrayal of American history and the way it binds people to a place over time is amazing. Highly recommended to fans of well-written mysteries that spotlight the injustices perpetrated against Native Americans throughout history as well as history buffs.


Synopsis:
In the hours before dawn at a local summer camp, Bureau of Indian Affairs archaeologist Syd Walker receives an alarming call: newly discovered skeletal remains have been stolen. Not only have bones gone missing, but a Native teen girl has disappeared near the camp, and law enforcement dismisses her family's fears.

As Syd investigates both crimes, she's drawn into a world of privileged campers and their wealthy parents—most of them members of the Founders Society, an exclusive club whose members trace their lineage to the first colonists and claim ancestral rights to the land, despite fierce objections from the local tribal community. And it's not the first time something—or someone—has gone missing from the camp.

The deeper Syd digs, the more she realizes these aren't isolated incidents. A pattern of disappearances stretches back generations, all leading to the Founders Society's doorstep. But exposing the truth means confronting not just the town's most powerful families, but also a legacy of violence that refuses to stay buried.

From the national bestselling author of Blood Sisters (a Washington Post Best Mystery of the Year and Target Book Club pick) comes a new Syd Walker novel that proves the sins of the past are destined to repeat until the truth is finally unearthed.

Sunday, October 12, 2025

The Haunting of Paynes Hollow Review

Author: Kelley Armstrong
Publisher: St. Martins Press
Release Date: Oct. 14, 2025

Many thanks to the publisher for a complimentary arc of this title for review. Opinions expressed are my own.

Review first published in Mystery & Suspense Magazine

From New York Times bestselling author Kelley Armstrong comes a nail-biting supernatural horror about a haunted lakeside property and twisted family secrets.

Review:
The Haunting of Paynes Hollow is a creepy, atmospheric, supernatural thriller that’s scheduled for release just in time for the spooky season. With an intriguing blend of folklore and the legend of the Headless Horseman, Author Kelley Armstrong delivers a chilling tale with paranormal vibes that's guaranteed to keep readers checking the locks on their doors as they read late into the night.  

Samantha Payne has been estranged from her grandfather for fourteen years when she's summoned to the reading of his Will. He hadn't spoken to Sam since her father, his son, committed suicide after being accused of the murder of a child at their lakefront cottage. Sam's grandfather went to his grave declaring his son's innocence in spite of what Sam witnessed in the woods all those years ago. Knowing he blamed her for her father’s death, no one was more surprised than Sam when she learns her grandfather left her the lakefront property, now worth millions, in hopes Sam will finally face the truth and admit she was mistaken. There's a stipulation, of course. Sam must reside in the family cottage on the lakefront for one month. Complete that simple task, and the property is hers. If she sells it, she'll have the funds to continue paying for her mother's care for dementia. What choice does she have? Sam moves to the cottage accompanied by her aunt and is surprised to find nothing has changed, including Ben, the property caretaker. Everything is exactly as she remembers from the days she spent there as a child right down to the bedding. 

Right away, Sam is perplexed over unsettling things occurring around her, including the sound of hoofs pounding, bizarre noises coming from the woods, unexplained lights flickering beneath the lake water, and most disturbing . . . the remains of mutilated animals left on her porch overnight. Tormented by nightmares and a rising sense of paranoia, Sam struggles to determine what's real and what's a mirage. When someone disappears, she’s forced to face the possibility that the rumors surrounding the cottage are true.

Dark family secrets that refuse to remain buried, a haunted cottage, and a murky lake with something lurking beneath the surface combine to set a tone of urgency in The Haunting of Paynes Hollow. As Sam's recessed memories begin surfacing, she has no choice but to take a hard look at some harsh childhood realities and reexamine her beliefs. As a protagonist, Sam makes some questionable decisions; however, her actions do not diminish the overall flow and entertainment value of this book. Armstrong sets a maddening pace that's fed by panic and a dark, tension ladened atmosphere of imminent danger. One that's strengthened by the eerie haunted cottage, dark woods, and lakeside setting that take on the role of another character in this sinister story. Readers should note trigger warnings that include mutilated animals, although they're not described in great detail.

Author Kelley Armstrong delivers another spooky, immersive, tautly written thriller for fans of light horror and paranormal mysteries. The Haunting of Paynes Hollow is the perfect, entertaining October story for those who enjoy books that raise the hair on the back of their neck with things that go bump in the night. Highly recommended.

 Synopsis:

When Samantha Payne’s grandfather dies, she figures she won’t even get a mention in the will. After all, she hasn’t seen him in fourteen years, not since her father took his own life after being accused of murdering a child at their lakefront cottage. Her grandfather always insisted her father was innocent, despite Sam having caught him burying the child’s body, his clothing streaked with blood.

But when she does attend the reading of the will at the behest of her aunt, she discovers that her grandfather left her the very valuable lakefront property where the family cottage sits. There’s one catch: Sam needs to stay in the cottage for a month. To finally face the fact she was wrong and her father was innocent, in her grandfather's words.

Traveling to Paynes Hollow, Sam is faced with the realities of her childhood and the secrets kept hidden in the shadows of her memories. When her aunt goes missing a couple days into their stay, Sam begins to question everything again. Plagued by nightmares and paranoia, she begins hearing sounds in the forest and seeing shapes crawling from the water as the rippling waves of the lake promise something unspeakably dark lurking just below their surface.
 

Monday, October 6, 2025

The Intruder Review

Author: Freida McFadden
Publisher: Poisoned Pen Press
Release Date: Oct.7, 2025

A big thank you to the publisher for a complimentary arc of this title for review. Opinions expressed in this review are my own.

This review first published in Mystery & Suspense Magazine

In this taut, deadly tale of survival and desperation, #1 New York Times bestselling author Freida McFadden explores how far one girl will go to save herself.

Review:
Author Freida McFadden always delivers creepy, astounding psychological thrillers that leave readers reeling while begging for more. Fortunately, the wait is never long as the prolific writer continues to write intense, jaw dropping stories at warp speed. Lock the doors and curl up in your favorite reading spot with plans to burn the midnight oil before cracking open the cover of The Intruder as there's no stopping until the final staggering passage.

Casey is a mysterious woman living alone in a remote, rundown cabin in the wilderness with a secretive neighbor’s place a half mile away as the crow flies and a lecherous landlord who often appears on her doorstep unexpected and unwelcome. Her past is a mystery to readers, but it's clear Casey's harboring a dark secret she’s determined to keep buried. As a deadly storm approaches, she scurries around trying to secure things and is startled by a face peering in her window. Or was it a tree branch blown around by the wind? When Casey goes outside to make one last check around the house, she finds a young, terrified girl wearing blood-soaked clothing and clutching a knife hiding in the shed, which isn’t a safe place to ride out the storm. Casey has no choice but to invite the girl into the cabin to spend the night. When the girl refuses to give up the knife or answer Casey's questions, she waits for the girl to go to sleep to snoop through her ragged bookbag, and what Casey discovers sends chills down her spine. How did this girl arrive at Casey's cabin miles from nowhere without a vehicle? Why is she here? The answers could end up costing Casey her life.

The Intruder checks all my boxes for a must-read, spooky psychological thriller including remote setting, increment weather, unknown imminent threat, twisted plot line, dual timelines, and shifting, unreliable narrators. While armchair detectives may reach some conclusions early, McFadden always has a last page, jaw-dropping ace up her sleeve that blindsides everyone in the end, and The Intruder may harbor the biggest one yet. The story is rendered through short, past/present chapters from the dual points of view of Casey and the young girl, Ella. The underlying eerie vibes of danger ramp up page by page, chapter by chapter, with each traumatic tidbit of information revealed setting a scene that's ominous at best and terrifying at worse. Casey and Ella are on a collision course with their past and each other with no way to stop it. Who will survive the night?

The Intruder is one of McFadden's darker psychological thrillers with some heavy themes such as childhood abuse, retribution, and redemption. Characters are realistic yet secretive, strong yet vulnerable. The story comes together piece by piece until readers may think they have it all figured out but wait for it. Remember, we're talking about the queen of last page, jaw-dropping shockers here so read on for the next sordid, mind-blowing twist, and the final no way bombshell reveal. Atmospheric, intense, and spine chilling, The Intruder is a masterpiece in the genre of psychological thrillers. This one would be brilliant playing out on the big screen. Fans of the genre will eat it up.

Synopsis: 
Who knows what the storm will blow in…

Casey's cabin in the wilderness is not built for a hurricane. Her roof shakes, the lights flicker, and the tree outside her front door is sways ominously in the wind. But she's a lot more worried about the girl she discovers lurking outside her kitchen window.

She’s young. She’s alone. And she’s covered in blood.

The girl won't explain where she came from or loosen her grip on the knife in her right hand. And when Casey makes a disturbing discovery in the middle of the night, things take a turn for the worse.

The girl has a dark secret. One she’ll kill to keep. And if Casey gets too close to the truth, she may not live to see the morning.